Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Personal Property Lending Panel
  • Moderator:  Marty Lavin
  • Speakers:   Don Glisson, Jr.
  •                    Andy Griggs
  •                    Ron Klein
  •                    Tim Williams
2
Historically, Manufactured Homes Were Financed as Chattel

  • 75-85% Chattel


  • Real Estate-secured gaining favor
3
Industry Activity Since 1990
  • Ramp up in early 1990s
  • GreenTree Financial leads with ABS
  • Very high home sales volume in mid 90s
  • Late 1990s volume drop
  • Early 2000s serious pull back
  • Mid 2000s leveling off
4
Why Is Money Hard to Find For Chattel Lending?
  • FICO Tiers
  • Charge offs
  • Land-lease Communities
5
Chattel Activity Fairly Constant in Middle 2000s
  • Little volume growth
  • New lenders enter
  • Attractiveness of other financing forms and their competition
6
Regaining Chattel Preponderance
  • Our panel covers all the funding sources of chattel money:
      • Banks
      • Credit Unions
      • ABS
      • Internal Funds
  • The intent of this panel is to discuss the present state of availability of money to fund chattel loans.
7
Introduction of Panel Members
  • Don Glisson, Jr. – Triad Financial Services, Inc.
  • Andy Griggs, CU Factory Built Lending
  • Ron Klein, Origen Financial
  • Tim Williams, 21st Mortgage Corp.
8
 
9
"5 Time MHI"
  • 5 Time MHI
  • Regional Lender of the Year
  • presented by
  • Don Glisson, Jr., President/CEO
10
Triad Financial Services Overview
  • Established 1959
  • Prime credit specialists
  • Office locations:
    • Jacksonville, FL (headquarters)
    • Bourbonnais, IL
    • Houston, TX
    • Western US Office TBA 3rd Quarter 2006
    • Conducting business in 39 states
11
2005 Results

  • Amount Financed increased 29%
  • Down Payments Averaged 17%
  • FICO scores Averaged Over 700
  • Delinquency less than 2%


  • 1st Quarter 2006 Amount Financed up 55% !!



12
2006 Industry Overview
  • New Home shipments 125,000 – 130,000 by our Estimation
  • New Home market $8.4 billion
  • Resale Home market 650,000-675,000 homes
  • Resale market dollar value: $22.5 billion
  • Resale Market Underserved even though it exceeds New Home Volume


13
Triad:  From Dictionary.com
“A Group of Three”
14
How Our “Triad” Helps the Industry Sell Chattel Financed Homes
15
How Triad Keeps the Money Flowing
16
Triad and Our Investors
17
 
18
Marketing Manufactured Homes to Investors:
The Credit Union Perspective
  • Andy Griggs, Director of Strategic Developments
  • CU Factory Built Lending, L.P.
19
Setting New Perceptions for Manufactured Homes
  • Improving the performance and perception of chattel secured manufactured home loans:
    • It is all about a stable and predictable ROA (Return on Assets)
    • Exit strategy must not be a lose-lose


20
Return on Assets
  • ROA is a function of:
    • Net interest income, and
    • Operating expenses, and
    • Charge-offs
  • ROA target or premium for an asset class is a function of:
    • Historical performance of asset, and
    • Credit risk (perceived and real), and
    • Hassle factor


21
Credit Risk =
  • Default Frequency
  • Loan Attributes
  • Credit score
  • Location of Home
  • Equity
  • Advance Rates
  • New/Used
  • Loan Terms
  • Documentation


  • Market attributes
  • Satisfaction with homes performance
  • “Appeal” of Home
  • Buyer/Community Commitment
  • Loss Severity
  • Disorganized and
  •     Fragmented Resale Market
  • Integrity of Collateral Data
22
Credit Union Industry Overview
  • Assets >$700 Billion
  • Membership > $ 85 Million
  • Capital > $ 75 Billion
  • RE 1st Mortgages           >$135 Billion
  • Auto Loans >$160 Billion
  • HELOCS >    36 Billion
  • Yield on
  • Average Assets 5.75%
  • ROA   .95%
  • Loan to Share          73%
  • Net Interest Margin 3.30%
  • Charge-Offs   .40%


  • # of Credit Unions over $1 Billion in Assets   94
  • # of Credit Unions with assets of 250 million - $1 Billion 424
23
CUFBL Loan Performance
24
Comparative Credit Score Stratification
25
National vs. CUFBL Comparative Income Profile
26
 
27
Why high interest rates cannot offset lending to weak credit borrowers:
  • Let’s look at the following three examples:


  • Each example has the following constants:
  • Each is over a 3 year average
  • The average outstanding balance over a 3 year period is $275,000,000
  • Default rate is for the weighted life of loan pool
  • The cost of funds is 5%
28
Example One
29
Example One Continued
30
Example Two
31
Example Two Continued
32
Example Three
33
Example Three Continued
34
 
35
Who Is Origen?
36
 
37
How Does Securitization Work?
38
What Are The Challenges              of Securitizing MH?
39
Why Did MH Loans Go Bad?
  • Over Advanced
  • Too Much House
  • Long Terms
  • Buydown Points
  • Poor Quality Product
  • Poor Service
  • Poor Installation
  • Over-Priced Options
  • Financed Insurance, Credit Life, “Extras”
  • No Verification of Customer Info-i.e. Insufficient Income


40
Anatomy of Loss
41
Performance Trends
42
 
43
A Sample Deal
  • $175,000,000 in loans, $156,187,000 sold as bonds, $19,000,000 as OC
  • Bond Pricing
  • 1 yr. AAA 5.50%
  • 3 yr. AAA 5.80%
  • 5 yr. AAA 6.00%
  • 10 yr. AAA 6.50%
  • AA 7.00%
  • A 7.50%
  • BBB 8.00%
  • OC = 11.00%
  • COF = 6.2%
  • Leverage = 8X


44
Cost Of Funds
45
How Can Origen Improve          Our Leverage?
46
How Can We Buy More, Lower Rates, & Save the World?
  • Re-Establish MH as a Performing Asset Class
  • Out-Perform Expectations
  • Create Value for Borrowers
  • Keep the Borrower’s Interest in Mind
47
Keys to Improving MH Securitization
  • Performance History and Data
    • Data driven underwriting, performance monitored and adjustments made DAILY
  • Transparency of Information
    • Loan level data and performance publicly available on website
  • Integrity in the Process
    • Loan structure – shorter terms, lower LTI, no “Air”
    • Verification and validation of information – VOI, VOE, VOD
    • Source diligence, fraud checks and audit feedback
  • Servicing know-how and execution
  • Customer NEEDS Real Value in Their Home!
48
“What If” Better Leverage Leads to Higher Returns
49
                    Positive Trends
  • Origen’s Demonstrated Performance Has Already Allowed Us To:
    • Improve Leverage
    • Narrow Spreads
    • Reduce Rates, Lower Rates Even More for Better Credits
    • Increase Approval Percentage
    • Offer New, Innovative Products
    • Gain Credibility With Investors
50

Division Clayton Homes Inc.
A Berkshire Hathaway Company
51
 
52
 
53
 
54
"Clayton borrows money from Berkshire"
  • Clayton borrows money from Berkshire, which in turn borrows the same amount publicly. For the use of its credit, Berkshire charges Clayton a one percentage-point markup on its borrowing cost. In 2005, the cost to Clayton for this arrangement was $83 million.
55
What we do at 21st Mortgage?
  • Finance Inventory ($200 Million)
  • Originate loans-Nationwide
    • Direct
    • Broker
    • Indirect (Retailer)
    • Portfolios
    • Land/home (single close and stage funding)
  • Service loans
    • Insurance
  • Liquidate repossessions
56
21st Mortgage Pricing
  • 21st estimates its cost of funds each month as if BRK was issuing new bonds each month
  • Every loan product has the same money cost regardless of credit quality
  • Each loan product has its own unique risk premium based upon default frequency and loss severity ratio
  • Servicing costs also vary by loan quality and loan size


57
Risk Modeling
  • Annual analysis of 100,000 loans
  • Default frequency
  • Credit score
  • Equity
  • Home Placement
  • Home type
  • Prepay frequency
58
Cumulative Repossession rate,
Park vs Non-Park,  95% LTV
59
"Other rate factors"
  • Other rate factors
  • Home type- SW, DW, Age
  • Location – Land/home, Private property Community
  • Community Attributes and Agreements